Donate a dead startup position, or sell it?

By Will Rogers, DivestMe · Updated November 2026

Someone has told you to donate the position to a charity or a donor-advised fund instead of selling it. For a holding that has gained value, that is familiar advice. For a private position that has stalled, a gift and a sale are two different events, and each one leaves a different record. This page sets out what each event is. It doesn’t say which one fits your position. That depends on your facts, and it’s your advisor’s call.

What a gift is

A gift transfers the position to a charity or a fund sponsor for nothing in return. It is a contribution, and a contribution is measured by what the property is worth on the day you give it.

IRS Publication 526 addresses property that has gone down in value directly: the contribution is limited to the property’s fair market value, and the difference between what you paid and that value can’t be claimed as a contribution.

So a gift does not record what you paid against what you received. It records a contribution, at the value on the date of the gift.

What “fair market value” asks of you

Fair market value is the price a willing buyer would pay a willing seller on the date of the gift. For a private position, that raises three practical questions.

  1. Will anyone accept it? Charities and fund sponsors decide case by case whether to take a private position.
  2. Can it be appraised? Above the IRS thresholds ($5,000 for most property, $10,000 for stock that isn’t publicly traded), the donor needs a qualified appraisal from an independent appraiser, reported on Form 8283. An appraiser needs information from the company. A company that has gone quiet may not supply it.
  3. What number does the appraiser arrive at? The last priced round is one input. The appraiser values the position as of the date of the gift.

What a sale is

A sale has a counterparty, a price, a signed agreement and a date. The record is the amount you paid for the position and the amount you received for it, both stated on a document, with the date ownership passed to someone else.

Side by side

A gift to a charity or fundA sale to an outside buyer
The eventA contributionA sale
Measured byFair market value on the date of the giftThe price received, against what you paid
Who else is neededA recipient willing to accept it; an appraiser above the thresholdsA buyer
The record afterwardThe recipient’s acknowledgment, Form 8283, the appraisalA counter-signed agreement and a dated record of completion
If the position later recoversIt belongs to the charityIt belongs to the buyer

Questions to bring to your advisor

  • What did I pay for this position, and when?
  • What is it plausibly worth today, and who could say so?
  • Has a charity or fund sponsor agreed to take it?
  • Which event, a contribution or a sale, fits my year, and by what date would it need to happen?

Where DivestMe fits

DivestMe is one way to complete a sale. It doesn’t arrange gifts, and it doesn’t tell you which path to take. A documented sale through DivestMe costs a flat $150 per position. DivestMe LLC is the buyer: it counter-signs the Asset Sale Agreement, takes the position outright, and delivers the executed agreement and a Certificate of Completion. The purchase price is nominal, $1.00, because a position with no market has no price to discover; the dollar is consideration, not a valuation. DivestMe documents the sale; what it means for your taxes is for you and your advisor. See how it works, or read selling vs. abandoning for the other paths an advisor may raise.

Frequently asked questions

Can I donate a private position to a donor-advised fund?

Some sponsors accept private securities and some don’t. Each decides case by case, and a position in a company that has stopped reporting is harder to place. Ask the sponsor before you plan around it.

What is a donated position measured by?

By its fair market value on the date of the gift. IRS Publication 526 says that for property that has gone down in value, the contribution is limited to that value, and the difference between your basis and that value can’t be claimed as a contribution. How that applies to your position is your advisor’s determination.

Do I need an appraisal?

Above the IRS reporting thresholds, a gift of property calls for a qualified appraisal by an independent appraiser, reported on Form 8283. The threshold is higher for stock that isn’t publicly traded than for other property. Your advisor can tell you which applies to what you hold.

Is the last funding round the value of my position?

Fair market value is the price a willing buyer would pay a willing seller on the date of the gift. A priced round from years ago is one input an appraiser may consider; it isn’t the answer by itself. The appraiser, not the donor, arrives at the number.

Does DivestMe handle donations?

No. DivestMe is one way to complete a sale. A documented sale costs a flat $150 per position; DivestMe LLC buys the position for a nominal $1.00 under a counter-signed agreement. It doesn’t arrange gifts, and it doesn’t tell you which path to take.

More in Your options

Also related

Will Rogers is the founder of DivestMe. He is not a CPA, EA, or attorney. This guide describes two events, a gift and a sale, and the record each one leaves. Your tax advisor decides which, if either, fits your position.

This page is general information, not tax or legal advice. Talk to your CPA, EA, or tax attorney about your own position.