Someone has told you to donate the position to a charity or a donor-advised fund instead of selling it. For a holding that has gained value, that is familiar advice. For a private position that has stalled, a gift and a sale are two different events, and each one leaves a different record. This page sets out what each event is. It doesn’t say which one fits your position. That depends on your facts, and it’s your advisor’s call.
What a gift is
A gift transfers the position to a charity or a fund sponsor for nothing in return. It is a contribution, and a contribution is measured by what the property is worth on the day you give it.
IRS Publication 526 addresses property that has gone down in value directly: the contribution is limited to the property’s fair market value, and the difference between what you paid and that value can’t be claimed as a contribution.
So a gift does not record what you paid against what you received. It records a contribution, at the value on the date of the gift.
What “fair market value” asks of you
Fair market value is the price a willing buyer would pay a willing seller on the date of the gift. For a private position, that raises three practical questions.
- Will anyone accept it? Charities and fund sponsors decide case by case whether to take a private position.
- Can it be appraised? Above the IRS thresholds ($5,000 for most property, $10,000 for stock that isn’t publicly traded), the donor needs a qualified appraisal from an independent appraiser, reported on Form 8283. An appraiser needs information from the company. A company that has gone quiet may not supply it.
- What number does the appraiser arrive at? The last priced round is one input. The appraiser values the position as of the date of the gift.
What a sale is
A sale has a counterparty, a price, a signed agreement and a date. The record is the amount you paid for the position and the amount you received for it, both stated on a document, with the date ownership passed to someone else.
Side by side
| A gift to a charity or fund | A sale to an outside buyer | |
|---|---|---|
| The event | A contribution | A sale |
| Measured by | Fair market value on the date of the gift | The price received, against what you paid |
| Who else is needed | A recipient willing to accept it; an appraiser above the thresholds | A buyer |
| The record afterward | The recipient’s acknowledgment, Form 8283, the appraisal | A counter-signed agreement and a dated record of completion |
| If the position later recovers | It belongs to the charity | It belongs to the buyer |
Questions to bring to your advisor
- What did I pay for this position, and when?
- What is it plausibly worth today, and who could say so?
- Has a charity or fund sponsor agreed to take it?
- Which event, a contribution or a sale, fits my year, and by what date would it need to happen?
Where DivestMe fits
DivestMe is one way to complete a sale. It doesn’t arrange gifts, and it doesn’t tell you which path to take. A documented sale through DivestMe costs a flat $150 per position. DivestMe LLC is the buyer: it counter-signs the Asset Sale Agreement, takes the position outright, and delivers the executed agreement and a Certificate of Completion. The purchase price is nominal, $1.00, because a position with no market has no price to discover; the dollar is consideration, not a valuation. DivestMe documents the sale; what it means for your taxes is for you and your advisor. See how it works, or read selling vs. abandoning for the other paths an advisor may raise.